Score: 9

"Great Stuff!"

submission: Preloader Tutorial (321)

date: May 20, 2008

This was a great tutorial. It told the audience what to do, step by step, and also did it in a clear, concise manner.
One part I particularly like was the breakdown of the ActionScript, which really helps in getting to understand what AS is all about.
One point that I could possibly make to improve, is maybe in a sequel, if you desire to make one, teach how to make animated preloaders as well as standard bar ones, since animated ones tend to be much more impressive.
However, a very well presented tutorial!

Score: 7

"Pretty Good"

submission: Spice up Your Flash

date: April 21, 2008

This is a pretty good tutorial. It explains everything quite basically, and might be a little hard to understand for some people who are very new to Flash. Also, the grammar could use some work.
However, this covers some concepts in Flash rather well- good effort.

Score: 9

"Really Good!"

submission: Charlie the Unicorn

date: April 16, 2008

Very nice animation, and the sound effects were well done. The use of colour lends itself to give an almost childlike feeling of wonder, something further emphasised by the way the two other Unicorns move, like they are toy unicorns that a child is playing with. Overall, a very finely presented movie, and well worthy of all the attention it gets.

Score: 5

"Blurring eh?"

submission: Blurring Tutorial

date: March 24, 2008

This was not overtly bad, but not especially impressive either.
It was very simple- probably too simple, given what you are trying to teach, which is a very simple task in itself. This might have been better in an included package with some other effects other than just blurring. Nevertheless, it was clear and quite easy to understand.

Score: 9

"Hilarity ensues..."

submission: Tom's Easter orgy

date: March 23, 2008

This was extremely bizarre, and made me seriously wonder about your mental condition. However it was wonderfully animated, and great humour (if a little crude). I have the feeling that the face on the rabbit laying that egg at the beginning will stay with me for a very long time... well done.

Score: 9

"Great Tutorial!"

submission: Blan's Guide to Buttons

date: March 23, 2008

This is really good. Nice, easy to understand instructions, with not much high-tech lingo that often confuses the new user of Flash.
The Easter eggs were a nice addition, if a little unnecessary.
Nice use of colour and sound as well.
Overall, a really good, and easy-to-use tutorial on buttons. Well done!

Score: 4

"Could have been better"

submission: Metal Gear Awesome 2.5

date: March 14, 2008

It wasn't too bad, though not on par with Egoraptor's work. The animation wasn't anything to write home about, though it got the job done. However serious work should be done to make the voice acting proper voice acting.

Score: 10

"Brilliant Stuff!"

submission: Smash Kingdom Melee

date: March 11, 2008

This was really good! Clean, crisp animation, and sound. The skits were very funny as well, and played up to many of the new inclusions in Super Smash Bros Brawl. Alvin-Earthworm's Sonic vs Mario sections was also a welcome addition, utilising some brilliant animation and sound effects.
Just Sublime!

Score: 10

"Mesmerising..."

submission: The Pen is Mightier...

date: March 8, 2008

This is brilliant. The music syncs really well with the graphics, and suit the overall theme of the movie very well. The crude opening belies a real gem beneath. Also, the remixed version of the Moonlight Sonata was excellent.
Very different from normal NG fare, keep up the good work.

Score: 10

"Nice"

submission: Tutorial: Deity Whistle

date: March 8, 2008

This is great for those people who want to raise their whistle level! Nice easily understood tips that should help us to keep away from that dreaded Garbage Whistle. 5/5